On Tuesday, Democrats in the 10th district will choose a candidate for Congress. I am supporting Ilya Sheyman because he will be an outstanding congressman who will aggressively and effectively promote the progressive agenda which I believe this country needs.
Unfortunately, this contest has turned into something that neither Ilya or I expected or wanted it to be. It has turned into a contest between Ilya, who represents the future of the party and the country, and his main opponent, who represents the timidity that has kept us from achieving our goals at the national level.
Ilya is supported by Russ Feingold, Howard Dean, Larry Suffredin, Daniel Biss, and Robyn Gabel, people who have fearlessly stood at the forefront of the progressive movement among Democrats. His opponent is supported by some of the national leadership of the right-leaning wing of the party, and by a handful of retiring local lawmakers.
Ilya wanted the campaign to be about ideas and values that will move this country forward. His opponent has turned it into a campaign about trying to trick Republicans into voting for a moderate Democrat instead of for Republican Bob Dold. As President Harry Truman said, that never works – Republicans will always choose the real Republican over the Democrat who is trying to appeal to Republicans.
The strangest thing about the campaign is that Ilya's opponent, who spent the entire campaign claiming to be just as progressive as Ilya, has now, in the final weeks, turned his campaign into an attack on Ilya for being too young and too liberal. He has called the progressive groups which support Ilya, which include MoveOn, the National Organization for Women, and the Sierra Club “outside special interests” and “extremists.”
Ilya's opponent has also attacked Ilya for sending out negative campaign literature and robocalls – even though the literature and calls were not sent by Ilya's campaign at all, but by a respected independent liberal group, MoveOn, which wanted to help Ilya but which did not understand the distaste the voters in this district have for negative campaigning. By law, Ilya's campaign was not allowed to even know about MoveOn's efforts, and in fact Ilya's campaign scrupulously followed the law. If it could have, I am sure Ilya's campaign would have asked MoveOn not to take such a negative approach. Ilya's campaign has not sent out a single robocall.
What Ilya's campaign did was tell the truth – that while Democrats worked to elect a Democrat in the district, year after year his opponent donated thousands of dollars to Republican Mark Kirk to help him get re-elected. Ilya's opponent has admitted that he made those donations. He has also admitted that he donated to a bunch of right-wing Republicans all over the country. He said he did it because they were good for Israel. He hasn't answered the charge that he is a single issue voter and contributor who seemed to have no concern that his donations were setting back innumerable causes, including women's health.
Nor has Ilya's opponent explained why he would think that Kirk would have been any better for Israel than any of Kirk's Democratic opponents. He has not explained why he supported Kirk and the other Republicans when they were helping Bush take our country into war and destroy our economy. All he has done is to complain that by telling the truth, Ilya has been negative. When someone said to Harry Truman, “Give 'em hell, Harry,” Truman replied, “I don't give them Hell, I just tell the truth about them and they think it's Hell.” All Ilya has done is to tell the truth.
I did not want to even address the “negativity” charges, but as we learned when John Kerry was Swiftboated, unfair charges can mislead the voters if they are not answered. I understand that Ilya's opponent does not have any experience in politics, and I will assume that he has simply taken bad advice in making the charges. But it is going to be difficult to unseat the current congressman, and we do not need a candidate who is unprepared to make sound decisions.
I hope this email does not contribute to the dissatisfaction that some people are feeling about the campaign, and I do not want anyone to refrain from voting because they think the rhetoric has become too heated. This has, until just these last days, been a very positive campaign all around. If mistakes were made, we must be mature enough to overlook them, and cast our votes based on what is real and what is important, not on matters of style. This has been a vigorous primary, and we should be proud of the efforts the candidates have made on our behalf. We are all going to have to pull together after the primary. Please, cast your vote for the candidate whom you believe will go to Washington and work hard to set this country on the right course. I think that person is Ilya.
Showing posts with label Ilya Sheyman Brad Schneider John Tree Vivek Bavda politics election progressive vote tenth 10th congress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ilya Sheyman Brad Schneider John Tree Vivek Bavda politics election progressive vote tenth 10th congress. Show all posts
Tuesday, March 20, 2012
Monday, March 19, 2012
Re-evaluating Ilya
Enough of the robocalls, mailings, poll results, endorsements, fund raising totals, accusations, and denials. Enough of inside baseball. A congressional campaign is not a sport; it is serious business. Voters want to know what the candidates stand for and what they will do. They want to be able to judge the candidates' characters, commitment, and abilities.
Very early in this campaign, I endorsed Ilya Sheyman. Since then, candidates have entered and left the race. I have listened to them all, and read all of their websites, mailings, and everything I could find that has been reported in the media and discussed in the blogs. I have talked with supporters of all of the candidates and with all of the candidates themselves. I have gotten to know many of Ilya's volunteers and campaign staff, and I have watched him at numerous debates and other events.
I am just as enthusiastic now as I was 12 months ago to have Ilya representing me in Congress. For me, the real question is who do I want, not who do I think can win. The truth is that with the district we now have, even though some of the candidates are saying they are the only ones who can win, there is no one candidate in the primary who is the only one who can win.
But the election isn't about who I want. It is about who the majority of voters want, and some of them undoubtedly want the country to take a different course than I do. I want everyone to have health care.
Not everyone agrees with me. A lot of people still think that whether you get to see a doctor should depend upon how much money you inherited, or where you work, or what pre-existing conditions you were blessed with.
I don't want us to attack Iran. Plenty of people do. They want us to control Iran's oil, or they hate Muslims, or they just want us to attack because that is what they think Israel wants and for them Israel is more important than anything else, even innocent people's lives.
I want rich people to support our government and our society by paying their share of taxes. Lots of rich people don't want to pay. Some of them are Democrats, and some of them pretend to be Democrats. But their wealth overrides everything else.
I want Social Security and Medicare to be preserved intact. There aren't a lot of absolutes in politics, but for me, whether to protect the source of security for elderly and disabled people is not open for discussion.
I want us to stop imprisoning people without trials, assassinating political opponents, spying on everyone, and generally denying people their rights. The President has disappointed me on these things, and I want someone who will stand up to the President.
I don't know for sure that Ilya and I agree on all of these things and on all other issues, but I know that for the most part, he and I see eye to eye. Only a certain kind of person goes to work as an organizer for progressive, grass-roots organizations like MoveOn and Democracy for America, as Ilya did. Only a certain type of person stands on the picket line with teachers when his job wasn't in jeopardy and he didn't have kids in the school, as Ilya has.
Only a certain type of person insists on making marriage equality a central issue in his campaign as a matter of principal, when it isn't an issue that people were asking about and it doesn't affect him personally. Ilya did. Only a certain kind of person volunteers to help people who have been released from prison, when most politicians are terrified of being called soft on crime. Ilya wasn't afraid to stand by people in need, even if they had made mistakes in the past. Only a certain kind of person champions the rights of immigrants at a time when they are being blamed for taking away American jobs. Ilya, an immigrant himself, took a stand.
Ilya is a man of principal. He is tough. He is smart. He is determined. He has shown in his campaign that he will stand up to political bosses and powerful special interest groups. He has chosen the path of public service at the outset of his career, and not just as something to do after spending a lifetime trying to accumulate wealth. He is an idealist and a realist and is remarkably capable.
This election, I get to vote for someone who really has the potential and the drive to make a difference. I know how difficult a task he will have if he is elected. He knows, too. And yet, he is eager to try.
I'm still for Ilya.
Very early in this campaign, I endorsed Ilya Sheyman. Since then, candidates have entered and left the race. I have listened to them all, and read all of their websites, mailings, and everything I could find that has been reported in the media and discussed in the blogs. I have talked with supporters of all of the candidates and with all of the candidates themselves. I have gotten to know many of Ilya's volunteers and campaign staff, and I have watched him at numerous debates and other events.
I am just as enthusiastic now as I was 12 months ago to have Ilya representing me in Congress. For me, the real question is who do I want, not who do I think can win. The truth is that with the district we now have, even though some of the candidates are saying they are the only ones who can win, there is no one candidate in the primary who is the only one who can win.
But the election isn't about who I want. It is about who the majority of voters want, and some of them undoubtedly want the country to take a different course than I do. I want everyone to have health care.
Not everyone agrees with me. A lot of people still think that whether you get to see a doctor should depend upon how much money you inherited, or where you work, or what pre-existing conditions you were blessed with.
I don't want us to attack Iran. Plenty of people do. They want us to control Iran's oil, or they hate Muslims, or they just want us to attack because that is what they think Israel wants and for them Israel is more important than anything else, even innocent people's lives.
I want rich people to support our government and our society by paying their share of taxes. Lots of rich people don't want to pay. Some of them are Democrats, and some of them pretend to be Democrats. But their wealth overrides everything else.
I want Social Security and Medicare to be preserved intact. There aren't a lot of absolutes in politics, but for me, whether to protect the source of security for elderly and disabled people is not open for discussion.
I want us to stop imprisoning people without trials, assassinating political opponents, spying on everyone, and generally denying people their rights. The President has disappointed me on these things, and I want someone who will stand up to the President.
I don't know for sure that Ilya and I agree on all of these things and on all other issues, but I know that for the most part, he and I see eye to eye. Only a certain kind of person goes to work as an organizer for progressive, grass-roots organizations like MoveOn and Democracy for America, as Ilya did. Only a certain type of person stands on the picket line with teachers when his job wasn't in jeopardy and he didn't have kids in the school, as Ilya has.
Only a certain type of person insists on making marriage equality a central issue in his campaign as a matter of principal, when it isn't an issue that people were asking about and it doesn't affect him personally. Ilya did. Only a certain kind of person volunteers to help people who have been released from prison, when most politicians are terrified of being called soft on crime. Ilya wasn't afraid to stand by people in need, even if they had made mistakes in the past. Only a certain kind of person champions the rights of immigrants at a time when they are being blamed for taking away American jobs. Ilya, an immigrant himself, took a stand.
Ilya is a man of principal. He is tough. He is smart. He is determined. He has shown in his campaign that he will stand up to political bosses and powerful special interest groups. He has chosen the path of public service at the outset of his career, and not just as something to do after spending a lifetime trying to accumulate wealth. He is an idealist and a realist and is remarkably capable.
This election, I get to vote for someone who really has the potential and the drive to make a difference. I know how difficult a task he will have if he is elected. He knows, too. And yet, he is eager to try.
I'm still for Ilya.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)